|
12 step program
the original 12 step
program is alcoholics anonymous* living the recovery programme-
which deals with what they call the "powerlessness" to stop drinking
alcohol. although the 12 steps have been adopted by other groups
including al-anon for people impacted by having or having had
alcoholics in their life, alcoholics anonymous and the 12 steps were
designed and are only intended for use by alcoholics. the only
requirement for membership of an alcoholics anonymous group "is the
desire to stop drinking".
other twelve-step
programs are similarly fellowships which aim to aid in the recovery
of the consequences of an obsession, addiction, a physical and
mental compulsion, or another harmful influence on their lives, with
the help of the faith-based twelve steps dependent on
reliance on "a power greater than ourselves". as is said in
alcoholics anonymous, it is not just a matter of putting the cork in
the bottle, the 12 step program deals with the underlying mental and
emotional causes of the obsession with alcohol (or other substances
in other programs based on the 12 steps of alcoholics anonymous).
these fellowships of
men and women, a bond of loosely organized, autonomous groups,
function on the basis of principles formulated in the twelve
traditions. synonyms are anonymous program and a-program; the
original twelve-step program is alcoholics anonymous (a.a), which
was started in the us. today there are meetings and fellowships all
over the world.
back to
top
characteristics
all twelve-step
programs follow some version of the twelve steps. members meet
regularly to discuss their problem(s) and share their victories.
common among all such programs is the view that members are dealing
with an illness rather than a bad habit or a maladaptive behavior,
that the illness is a combination of an allergy of the body that
creates uncontrollable cravings coupled with an obsession of the
mind that keeps finding rationalizations for returning to that which
causes the cravings, and that recovery from the illness can occur by
abandonment of individual will through the twelve steps. true to the
twelve traditions, twelve-step programs do not take positions on
outside issues such as medical ones. the word "illness" rather than
"disease" was used by bill wilson, a co-founder of a.a. and the
drafter of the big book, alcoholics anonymous (which was co-written
by the first hundred men to find recovery in a.a.).
one of the most
widely-recognized characteristics of twelve-step groups is the
requirement that members admit that they "have a problem". in this
spirit, many members open their address to the group along the lines
of, "hi, i'm pam and i'm an alcoholic" — a catchphrase now widely
identified with support groups.
attendees at group
meetings share their experiences, challenges, successes and
failures, and provide peer support for each other. many people who
have joined these groups report they found success that previously
eluded them, while others — including some ex-members — criticize
their efficacy or universal applicability. thus there is some
controversy about twelve-step programs.
the twelve steps - living the recovery programme
these are the twelve
steps as defined by alcoholics anonymous
1. we admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had
become unmanageable.
2. came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could
restore us to sanity.
3. made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the
care of god as we understood him.
4. made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
5. admitted to god, to ourselves, and to another human being the
exact nature of our wrongs.
6. were entirely ready to have god remove all these defects of
character.
7. humbly asked him to remove our shortcomings.
8. made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing
to make amends to them all.
9. made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except
when to do so would injure them or others.
10.
continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong
promptly admitted it.
11.
sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious
contact with god, as we understood him, praying only for
knowledge of his will for us and the power to carry that out.
12.
having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these
steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice
these principles in all our affairs.
other twelve-step
groups have modified the twelve steps slightly from those of
alcoholics anonymous to refer to problems other than alcoholism.
back to
top
history
the first such
program was alcoholics anonymous (aa), which was begun in 1935 by
bill wilson and dr. bob smith, known to a.a. members as "bill w."
and "dr. bob." in akron, ohio. they established the tradition within
the "anonymous" twelve-step programs of using only first names. the
twelve steps were originally written by wilson and other early
members of aa to codify the process that they felt had worked for
them personally. the twelve steps were essentially a rewriting of
the 6 steps of the oxford group (founded by frank buchman)with whom
wilson had contact. this "codex" is the book alcoholics anonymous,
often referred to as the "big book."
after the unusual
cures were realized by bob and bill, the akron group authorized
wilson to write a book about the program. but wilson returned to new
york and wrote an entirely different program based primarily on what
he had learned from the rev. samuel m. shoemaker, jr., rector of
calvary episcopal church in new york, and a leader of the oxford
group people in america. to shoemaker's ideas, which are found
almost verbatim in the twelve steps, bill added in his big book (the
new basic text) ideas about alcoholism from dr. william d. silkworth,
ideas about the necessity for a conversion from dr. carl g. jung,
ideas about a so-called "higher power" primarily from professor
william james and new thought writers, thoughts from anne smith's
(dr. bob's wife) spiritual journal, practical techniques from
richard peabody set forth in his common sense of drinking book, and
a smattering of words and phrases with new thought and new age
origin such as "universal mind," "czar of the universe," "fourth
dimension of existence," and "higher power." then wilson declared
there had been a program of recovery which consisted of twelve steps
the pioneers had taken to find god. bill asked shoemaker to write
the steps, but shoemaker declined. the steps can be recognized in
the oxford group teachings wilson received from rowland hazard and
ebby thacher in late 1934 and early 1935, but neither the oxford
group nor early a.a. in new york or akron had any "steps" at all.
a.a. was, at its
origins, most assuredly a "religion" and a "religious organization."
the concept of "spiritual, not religious," seems to have derived
from the desire to keep religion separate from a.a. even though the
precepts and practices of a.a. were biblical in roots and nature.
thus early a.a. meetings in new york were those of "a first century
christian fellowship" then also known as the "oxford group." the
"spirituality" idea was originally defined by wilson as reliance on
the creator.
some say that since
the publication of the book "alcoholics anonymous," new thought and
new age substitute words have driven a.a. talk and writing towards
unbelief and substitutionary, secular universalism rather than
toward a relationship with god — the avowed big book purpose of the
steps. then again, a.a. circuit speakers can often be heard to say
things like "if 'god' ran you out of a.a., alcoholism can run your
rusty ass back in again."
the twelve steps were
eventually matched with twelve traditions, a set of guidelines for
running individual groups and a sort of constitution for the
fellowship (i.e., a.a.) as a whole.
many other programs
since have adapted aa's original steps to their own ends. related
programs exist to help family and friends of those with addictions
as well as those with problems other than alcohol. these programs
also follow modified versions of the twelve steps of alcoholics
anonymous and include groups like al-anon/alateen, overeaters
anonymous (oa), gamblers anonymous (ga), narcotics anonymous (na),
and nar-anon.
one organization
which is often confused with an "anonymous" twelve-step program, due
to the intentional similarity of its name — but is not one —
is narconon. narconon is a branch of the church of scientology,
presenting scientology doctrine and practices as a therapy for drug
abusers. narconon does not use the twelve steps, and is not related
to either narcotics anonymous (na) or to nar-anon, despite the
similarity of names.
back to
top
acceptance of a
higher power
a primary belief of
members is that their recovery requires them to give up their
self-reliance and willpower, and to put their reliance on god, or a
"higher power". proponents of twelve-step programs argue that
agnostics and even atheists can be helped by the program as a
member’s "higher power" may be the 12-step group itself or any other
entity, thing or object that helps a member to accept that they are
powerless over their problem but that a belief in a "higher power"
will help them to recover.
the success of
twelve-step groups in aiding in recovery of addictive illnesses is
an argument of significance in some parts of the united states,
where the criminal justice system has ordered 12-step group
participation to convicted felons as well as inmate addicts as a
condition of parole or shortened sentences. u.s. judges have often
required attendance at aa meetings as a condition of probation or
parole or as an element of a sentence for defendants convicted of a
crime. the new york court of appeals ruled in griffin v. coughlin,
88 n.y.2d 674 (1996) that doing so compromises the establishment
clause of the united states constitution on the grounds that a.a.
practices and doctrine are (in the words of the district court judge
who wrote the decision) "unequivocally religious". the united states
supreme court denied certiorari and let this decision stand.
critics of the
12-step programs, however, often hold that this reliance is
ineffective, and offensive or inapplicable to atheists and others
who do not believe in a salvific deity. other critics see forms of
authoritarian mind control in the 12 step approach.
some critics state
that 12-step groups are religious in nature. the only authorized
literature in most 12-step groups is their own publications. the
members of 12-step groups make the distinction that they are
"spiritual, and not religious." nearly every meeting begins with the
serenity prayer, a prayer addressed to "god." the big book states
that its "main object" is not to help you stop drinking, but "to
enable you to find a power greater than yourself which will solve
your problem." although in some meetings it may be unusual to find
participants who do not find their "higher power" to be the
christian deity, it can be useful for anyone regardless of their
religious belief.
some critics also
question the idea of giving up on self-reliance, which can be seen
as a form of idealized despair. secular alternatives to twelve-step
programs, such as rational recovery, are for this reason in many
ways opposite to the twelve-step process. others, such as yes
recovery, acknowledge a debt to the twelve-steps movement but do not
have a culture of belief in god.
back to
top
relation to religion
the original a.a.
program fashioned in akron was described as a christian fellowship,
held "old fashioned prayer meetings," stressed bible study and
prayer and the reading of religious literature, and aimed to bring
people to an acceptance of jesus christ as the way to a relationship
with god.
while meetings were
held by alcoholics and oxford group members, the work was said to be
that of a "clandestine lodge" of the oxford group because its stress
was on helping alcoholics to recovery, abstinence, resistance of
temptation, old fashioned revival meetings, and conversion to christ
— which seemed to derive from the ideas, principles and practices of
united christian endeavor society of dr. bob's youth.
according to its
supporters, the program achieved a 75% to 93% success rate. at dr
bob's funeral, bill w said that he thought the success rate was
closer to 5%. its adherents said they felt the answer to their
problems was in the "good book" (as they called the bible). there
were no steps, no basic text, only one regular meeting. the emphasis
was on bible study, prayer, seeking god's guidance, conversion,
visiting hospitalized alcoholics, fellowship and witnessing. in a
word, it was called "love and service" — the watchwords of united
christian endeavor.
there are many
different ways of interpreting the intent behind twelve-step
programs. and as with the bible, there are those who argue strongly
for a relatively literal adherence to program literature, and then
there are those who advise "take what you like and leave the rest"
and advocate a much more liberal approach. (note: the phrase "take
what you like and leave the rest" cannot be found in the basic text
of aa or any other a.a. literature. the big book makes it abundantly
clear that following the 12 steps to the letter is one powerful way
for an alcoholic of the kind described in the big book to stay
sober, although it also says clearly that aa has no monopoly on the
truth.) two books that look at the twelve-step literature from a
more liberal point of view are the zen of recovery by mel ash
and a skeptic's guide to the twelve steps by phillip z.
another book, "the recovery spiral: a pagan path to healing" by
cynthia jane collins, looks at the 12 steps through a pagan
perspective.
back to
top |